Notu Cars

2016 BMW X1 problems and complaints

Owners have filed 160 complaints with NHTSA about the 2016 BMW X1. The most-reported problem area is powertrain (34 complaints), followed by visibility and wipers (20) and structure and body (17). The complaints report 1 crash, 1 fire and 4 injuries. NHTSA lists 3 safety recalls for this model year.

Complaints
160
Recalls
3
Crashes
1
Fires
1
Injuries
4
Deaths
0

What owners report about the 2016 BMW X1

Complaints by problem area. A complaint can name more than one area, so the bars add up to more than 160.

Powertrain
34
Visibility and wipers
20
Structure and body
17
Electrical system
13
Brakes
9
Engine
8
Air bags
4
Steering
4
Suspension
4
Speed control
3
Driver assistance
2
Wheels and tires
2
Seat belts
2
Fuel and propulsion
1
Lighting
1

Most-reported specific components

Structure › Body
15
Structure › Interior panels › Ceiling
2
Power train › Automatic transmission › Lever and linkage › Floor shift
2
Visibility › Sun/moon roof assembly
2
Electrical system › Instrument panel › Speedometer/odometer
1
Lane departure › Blind spot detection
1
Forward collision avoidance › Automatic emergency braking
1
Electrical system › Instrument cluster/panel
1

How the 2016 compares with other BMW X1 years

The 2016 model year has the most complaints of 14 BMW X1 model years on record. Counts are not adjusted for sales, and newer model years have had less time to collect complaints.

2013 392014 552015 522016 1602017 1562018 602019 132020 132021 112023 712024 302025 17

All BMW X1 model years

Mileage when the problem was reported

Based on the 36 complaints that gave a mileage. Half of them were filed at 42,000 miles or less.

Under 25K miles
10
25K–50K miles
15
50K–75K miles
8
75K–100K miles
1
100K–125K miles
0
125K–150K miles
2
150K+ miles
0

When the complaints were filed

Complaints NHTSA received each calendar year about the 2016 BMW X1. First on Jul 18, 2016, most recent on Nov 12, 2026.

View as table
Year receivedComplaints
20164
20174
20182
20197
202015
202126
202230
202338
202423
20259
20262

2016 BMW X1 recalls

3 recall campaigns on record, newest first. A recall may cover only some vehicles of this model year. Check your VIN at NHTSA to see whether a recall is open on a specific car.

Structure › Body › Roof and pillars

NHTSA campaign 19V349000 · Filed May 9, 2019 · 106,182 vehicles potentially affected

Defect
BMW of North America, LLC (BMW) is recalling certain 2016-2019 X1 sDrive28i and X1 xDrive28i vehicles. In the event of a crash where the occupants head contacts the B-pillar, the pillar may not absorb an adequate amount of the impact. As such, these vehicles fail to comply with the requirements of Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) number 201, "Occupant Protection in Interior Impact."
Risk
In the event of a crash, the insufficient impact absorption can increase the risk of injury.
Remedy
BMW will notify owners, and dealers will replace the vertical trim pieces on the upper portion of the interior B-Pillars, free of charge. Interim letters notifying owners of the safety risk were mailed July 1, 2019. Second notices will be sent as parts become available, starting on September 27, 2019. Owners may contact BMW customer service at 1-800-525-7417.

Seat belts › Front › Retractor

NHTSA campaign 16V747000 · Filed Oct 17, 2016 · 15,455 vehicles potentially affected

Defect
BMW of North America, LLC (BMW) is recalling certain model year 2016-2017 X1 sDrive28i, X1 xDrive28i, MINI Hardtop 4 Door Cooper, Mini Hardtop 4 Door Cooper S, MINI Cooper Clubman, and Cooper S Clubman, 2017 Rolls-Royce Ghost, and 2016 528i vehicles. The vehicle-sensitive locking mechanism of the seat belt Emergency Locking Retractor (ELR) for the driver's seat may not lock as designed. As such, these vehicles fail to comply with the requirements of the Federal Motor Vehicle Safety Standard (FMVSS) number 209, "Seat Belt Assemblies."
Risk
In the event of a crash where heavy braking is applied, the Emergency Locking Retractor (ELR) may activate when the occupant is more forward in the seat, possibly increasing the risk of injury.
Remedy
BMW will notify owners, and dealers will replace the driver's seat belt assembly, free of charge. The recall began July 3, 2019. Owners may contact BMW customer service at 1-800-525-7417.

Steering › Gear box (other than rack and pinion)

NHTSA campaign 15V887000 · Filed Dec 30, 2015 · 2 vehicles potentially affected

Defect
BMW of North America, LLC (BMW) is recalling one model year 2016 MINI Cooper Hardtop 2 Door vehicle manufactured November 24, 2015, and one BMW X1 Sports Activity Vehicle (SAV) manufactured October, 19 2015. The steering gearbox may have been manufactured with incorrect parts.
Risk
A gearbox malfunction may cause a loss of vehicle control and increase the risk of a crash.
Remedy
BMW will replace the steering gearbox, free of charge. Affected vehicles are located in dealer inventory and will be remedied before customer retail. The recall began on December 28, 2015. Owners may contact BMW customer service at 1-800-525-7417.

What 2016 BMW X1 owners wrote

The 40 most recent of 160 complaints, exactly as filed with NHTSA. These are owners' own accounts and have not been verified.

Nov 12, 2026 · 55,160 miles · MA

Parking brake · Power train

The contact owns a 2016 BMW X1. The contact stated that while attempting to park the vehicle, the message “Parking not Secure - Vehicle May Roll” message was displayed. The vehicle was taken to an independent mechanic where it was diagnosed with shifter cable assembly failure. The contact was informed that the shifter cable assembly needed to be replaced. The contact stated that the failure was a known failure with the vehicle. The dealer was contacted and made aware of the failure. The manufacturer was contacted, and a case was filed. The contact was informed that the repair was not covered under warranty. The failure mileage was approximately 55,160.

NHTSA ID 11777631

Jan 5, 2026 · WA

Unknown or other

Known HVAC-produced moisture drainage issue that cause water to get trapped inside the system and cabin air filter housing, causing significant mold or mildew to grow on the filter itself and spread spores through cabin ventilation system and contaminates air inside cabin which poses serious health hazards.

NHTSA ID 11708977

Jun 17, 2025 · WV

Engine · Fuel/propulsion system

- Roof and pillars I have been having for almost a year when trying to open and slide on the track. It is harsh and noisy. - Engine oil filter housing and coolant leak. This issue is critical. Finally on April 10, 2025 I ended spending $1007.52 to get the housing replaced to stop the ongoing drip drip effect. - Steering gear box. This issue remains despite the fact that I replaced struts. For almost a year since I bought the vehicle, there appears to be a clunking type noise especially when going over rail tracks on the road where I am forced to almost come to a complete stop to let the car go over the tracks out of fear of sustaining damage.

NHTSA ID 11667511

Jun 9, 2025 · 135,400 miles · VA

Electrical system › Instrument panel › Speedometer/odometer

Odometer Fraud. The contact purchased a 2016 BMW X1. The contact stated that it was discovered that there was a mileage discrepancy. The vehicle was a dealer sale. At the time of purchase, the vehicle mileage was 81,295, and at the time of registration, it was discovered that the mileage was 135,400.

NHTSA ID 11665898

Jun 2, 2025 · CA

Visibility/wiper

About 24 months back the sunroof curtain of my BMW X1 started having problems when I retract or operate it. It used to make stretching noises when I tried to open my sunroof and after a few times I heard a crackling noise and before I can stop it the curtain tore. Initially it was a small tear, so it did not bother much but over time the curtain completely left the guide/rail on one side and started sagging. Given it is a sunroof the curtain is as long as the vehicle and so now it is sagging to a point that it obstructs driver's visibly in back mirror. BMW won't do anything about it saying it is out of warranty and ultimately to avoid accidents I had to remove the curtain completely. I also tried getting it fixed, but the issue is not just the curtain but the rails of the curtain which is a non-replaceable part :( I would have to replace full sunshade assembly which is upwards of $1600. Also, it seems to be a common problem with these vehicles. Here are more examples of it: [XXX] . Please help me and other drivers be safe on the road. INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)

NHTSA ID 11664440

Jun 2, 2025 · OR

Unknown or other

My 2016 BMW X1 28i is leaking coolant. I am also getting a smell of something burning inside the car when driving. This is consistent with problems associated with the 2024 recall for water pump. I was told by my dealership that my vehicle was not one affected by the recall. I think it might be one that is. The vehicle could catch fire if there is a failure of the wiring.

NHTSA ID 11664401

May 8, 2025 · NY

Structure › Interior panels › Ceiling

Sunroof shade came off the tracks and is now sagging partially obstructing the view of my rear view mirror, if this sags more or falls off completely I will be unable to see out the rear window and can cause a collision. I see this has been an issue with multiple vehicles and should be addressed with the company immediately.

NHTSA ID 11659743

Apr 26, 2025 · PA

Power train

Every time I get in or out of my car, the secure vehicle against rolling indicator light comes on.

NHTSA ID 11656952

Jan 28, 2025 · TN

Unknown or other

Error message when getting in the truck says “Secure vehicle against rolling”.

NHTSA ID 11639150

Jan 17, 2025 · NJ

Power train

The car is indicating the I need to press the parking brake to secure the car from rolling after I have placed it in park and pressed the electronic parking brake.

NHTSA ID 11636409

Jan 8, 2025 · CT

Unknown or other

"Secure vehicle from rolling" keeps coming on the dashboard when I turn the car off or put into park.

NHTSA ID 11634955

Dec 5, 2024 · TX

Tires

225/50 R18. Purchased in March 2024 and tread is already at 4/32 and 5/32 as of Dec 2024 for 2 of them. Tires driven for 13K miles. This is completely unacceptable and unsafe. I believe there is a defect, for tires to be so new and tread to be degrading so quickly.

NHTSA ID 11628993

Dec 4, 2024 · MD

Unknown or other

After I got my 2016 BMW X1 from Service, I heard a rough sound when I reversed the vehicle from Park. After a few days, I noticed my vehicle showing an error saying "Secure Vehicle against rolling" every time I parked the vehicle and advising me to use my hand brake. I then did some search on the web and finally took it for servicing at BMW Rockville, Maryland where the service department is managed by Auto Nation. They gave me a quote for around $2500 to fix this issue. Based on the research of this issue on the web, it looks like a $10 spring malfunction causes this issue. I have less than 55,000 miles on my vehicle. I am not sure if this issue is caused by some incorrect service work performed by Auto Nation The report from Auto Nation is at the link below [XXX] INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)

NHTSA ID 11628788

Dec 3, 2024 · CA

Unknown or other

My 2016 X1 is showing in the dashboard a “secure vehicle against rolling” transmission message; the fault is due to a little spring in the selector level which has been reported in other BMW and MINI models. I recently found a report in the NHTSA website related to a 10 year warranty extension for the Mini [XXX] ) but it does not include the X1 model, which suffers from the same type of defect. The warning showed up for the first time on Tuesday [XXX]. I have made an appointment with the car dealer to diagnose the issue. Multiple X1 owners have reported the same issue in multiple forums, for example: [XXX] [XXX] INFORMATION REDACTED PURSUANT TO THE FREEDOM OF INFORMATION ACT (FOIA), 5 U.S.C. 552(B)(6)

NHTSA ID 11628459

Nov 19, 2024 · SC

Service brakes

Warning light stating "Secure vehicle against rolling". Even when the vehicle is in park it could still roll and injure or kill someone.

NHTSA ID 11626264

Nov 7, 2024 · NY

Unknown or other

Message-secure vehicle from rolling

NHTSA ID 11624094

Oct 24, 2024 · 46,000 miles · NH

Power train › Automatic transmission › Lever and linkage › Floor shift

The contact owns a 2016 BMW X1. The contact stated that after arriving to the destination and shifting the vehicle into park(P), the message "Secure Vehicle against Rolling Malfunction" was displayed. There was no warning light illuminated. The vehicle was taken to the dealer, who diagnosed a failure with the transmission shifter lever control cable. The contact was informed that the transmission shifter lever control cable was abnormally stretched. The vehicle was not repaired. The manufacturer was not notified of the failure. The failure mileage was 46,000.

NHTSA ID 11621777

Oct 4, 2024 · MO

Power train

The transmission lock sensor is defective in this car design- the spring in the gearshift assembly that contacts the transmission lock sensor has a faulty design and is prone to breaking. This leads to a warning in the car that the transmission lock has not occurred when the car is in park (although it is actually functioning). This creates a "false alarm" situation that then does not allow the user to know if the transmission is truly locked in park This defect has occurred in my car as diagnosed by both dealer and independent mechanic. This is a common and known defect amongst X1 owners (as well as the mechanical sibling Mini Cooper). It is also well known amongst the BMW dealer service; It should be consider a recall defect

NHTSA ID 11618197

Aug 30, 2024 · TX

Structure › Body

Sunroof shade ripped off

NHTSA ID 11611775

Aug 25, 2024 · TX

Electrical system

Received an error message: Transmission. Use parking break to prevent rolling. Dealership said it was the internal gear shift. It didn’t recognize the vehicle was in park. It was an expensive repair because they had to remove the console to fix. Was told it was an issue with my model.

NHTSA ID 11610691

Jul 22, 2024 · CA

Unknown or other

My car just started showing an error code every time I turn it off or on saying to "Secure vehicle with parking brake when stopped" with a transmission status error code but is running perfectly fine.

NHTSA ID 11603918

Jul 22, 2024 · OH

Power train

Secure vehicle from rolling error. Secure vehicle with parking brake Spring pin broke in side gear shifter.

NHTSA ID 11603681

Jul 17, 2024 · FL

Service brakes · Engine · Power train

Every time I start or stop my vehicle I get a notification that shows Transmission: Secure vehicle with parking brake when stopped. Consult service center. And my console has a hazard warning that shows: Secure vehicle against rolling. This happens every time, even if the car is parked on a completely flat surface in no danger whatsoever of rolling. I've read SEVERAL X1 owners get this message and all state this needs to be a RECALL. They take their vehicles in for service and are told it's between $2500 and $3000 due to a tiny spring that breaks and the selector no longer communicates with the car in the parking position, and because of this there is an error message in dashboard in which warns you to make sure the vehicle is secure

NHTSA ID 11602851

Jun 28, 2024 · MN

Power train

Keep getting the following warning "Transmission - secure vehicle with parking brake". It seems this is a known issue relating to a simple spring in the gear shifter that causes the computer to not recognize that the vehicle is in park. It's not only a very expensive repair for such a simple part failure, but also a safety concern in not knowing if the vehicle is secure to park.

NHTSA ID 11597421

May 26, 2024 · MN

Unknown or other

During the parking of the vehicle (gearbox shifter in “Park Position") and after turning off the engine, the iDrive system shows the following message: “Secure vehicle with parking brake and have the problem checked by dealership. This happens when I start up the vehicle in park and when turning off the vehicle. Also, when the vehicle is parked on level ground the error will remain even if the parking brake is applied. After turning on the engine again and putting the shifter either in R or D position, the error goes away. Dealership error computer diagnostic shows the code “420106” - Shift Lock solenoid: Selector lever wrongly not locked in Park. I shared with the dealership that this is a manufacturer problem and if they could fix it for free or give me a discount to fix the problem due to safety issues and I was told “No” I have to pay the total cost to repair this problem. Currently I am still driving a vehicle that can increase my risk of injury and the injury of bystanders. I purchased this vehicle after I retired because BMW makes good vehicles and this would be the last car I would purchase in my life.

NHTSA ID 11590832

Apr 17, 2024 · IL

Structure › Body · Seat belts · Lane departure › Blind spot detection

Steering Geer Box Structure body Roof and Pillars Seat belt retractors Air bags frontal

NHTSA ID 11583481

Apr 15, 2024 · IL

Unknown or other

Dash keeps reading secure vehicle against rolling. I believe it may be something with the gear shifter.

NHTSA ID 11583140

Apr 4, 2024 · TX

Unknown or other

It is showing "SECURE VEHICLE AGAINST ROLLING". what does this mean? Why would the vehicle roll?!

NHTSA ID 11581255

Mar 27, 2024 · CO

Service brakes

Repeatedly getting warnings of "secre vehicle with parking brake"

NHTSA ID 11579739

Feb 19, 2024 · WA

Unknown or other

Error message stating “secure vehicle from rolling”. This is a common issue with the X1. I’ve found countless complaints of the issue on BMW forums. Dealers are quoting $3000-$3500 for the repairs due to the time it takes to repair. BMW has in some cases acknowledged the issue and provided repair as a goodwill gesture but has yet to issue a recall for this known issue.

NHTSA ID 11572817

Feb 10, 2024 · MA

Power train

Secure vehicle against rolling error displayed despite the fact the car is securely in Park. Issue is a broke $1 spring inside the gearshifter that requires $4000 to fix at dealership. This is a poor quality issue driving a cash cow at the dealership ls with many people complaining online about this issue. It should be a recall

NHTSA ID 11571195

Jan 24, 2024 · WA

Power train

Please note that this is NOT the result of an accident. The car is a 2016 BMW X1 model which we have purchased in July 2020 as a BMW certified vehicle from a BMW dealer. Starting in December 2023 the car dashboard shows a warning light saying Secure Vehicle from Rolling. I have read that is it due to a broken pin in the transmission and it seems a common problem in 2016-17 BMWs X1 . BMW should have issued a recall . Again, there was NO accident.

NHTSA ID 11567650

Jan 18, 2024 · CO

Suspension · Unknown or other

Front left strut and right motor mount failed at less than 40K miles. Vehicle was not driven off road and was not in any accidents. This seems extremely early for such a failure. BMW dealer noted there was a "bulletin" on this model that if one strut failed, the pair should be replaced. It seems there may be a larger issue and possibly the need for a safety recall. Water pump also failed

NHTSA ID 11566252

Jan 5, 2024 · MA

Unknown or other

When turning car on and off error message “Secure Vehicle against rolling”. Everything shifts completely fine in the car, the parking brake engages and the car shifts into park fine. I’ve been told by dealer to bring in for $199 to do an assessment. I see on line this is a common issue and dealers charge between $2000 and $3000 to repair. I submit that this issue should be corrected by BMW through a recall.

NHTSA ID 11563719

Dec 26, 2023 · TN

Unknown or other

Secure transmission from rolling light keeps coming on when I try to get out of park. ….drive shifter needs to be replaced. Estimated $2400!!!!! This should be a recall issue. .

NHTSA ID 11561841

Dec 26, 2023 · SC

Unknown or other

The following warning came up on my car: secure vehicle with parking brake when stopped. Consult service center. The problem is a gear selector replacement. This small faulty spring costs only $10 but because of where it is located in the car will cost close to $4,000 to fix; it’s a well-known problem in X1s. This should be recalled.

NHTSA ID 11561817

Dec 20, 2023 · CA

Power train

Many X1 owners have reported the "Secure Vehicle Against Rolling Error" online in forums once the vehicle hits 100K miles. BMW is charging customers over $3K to fix a worn out spring that costs less than $10 on eBay. This should be under recall!

NHTSA ID 11561140

Dec 15, 2023 · WA

Suspension

2016 BMW X1 - 16,500 miles. When the car is in idle and the wheel is turned left or right it makes a groaning sound. The dealer says the strut mounts failed, and they need to take out the spring shocks, replace the mounts, and realign the vehicle. The vehicle is out of warranty (warranty was 4 yrs or 50,000 miles). When I look on BMW forums I see numerous other X1 owners had this issue at low mileages such as 300, 5000, 7000, 18000, 25000, etc miles. And that on 11/1/16 BMW knew of this defective part, that affected vehicles produced from 7/1/15 to 9/29/16, and issued TSB: SI B31 05 16. However, BMW did not notify owners of the defective part so it could be repaired while the car was under warranty.

NHTSA ID 11560386

Dec 13, 2023 · CA

Engine · Power train · Vehicle speed control

having an issue with the warning light saying Secure Vehicle from Rolling. gear selector replacement Needed. Shifter Linkage needed replacing

NHTSA ID 11560025

Dec 4, 2023 · CA

Visibility/wiper

The power sunshade came loose and dropped one side of the sunshade to the drivers side because it came loose

NHTSA ID 11558362

Source: NHTSA complaint and recall records, complaints received through Nov 18, 2026. How we count